First Impressions
About halfway through "Doom Painting", I realised I'd lost track of who was who and what was happening, so I did something I rarely do: I went back to the beginning and started again. That isn't a complaint. The writing was so rich and accomplished that I knew this was a novel worth taking the time to understand as fully as possible. I had a similar experience with Hilary Mantel's "Wolf Hall", whose beginning I reread before doing some additional reading around it to get the full context. On my second reading of the first half of "Doom Painting", I was much more plugged into what was going on.
A. K. Blakemore's third novel is an excellent, immersive account of the brief, infamous uprising known as the Peasants' Revolt. Over sixteen days in the summer of 1381, the "True Commons" of Essex and Kent rose against a punitive poll tax. They weren't only peasants: there were reeves, brewers, boatwrights, a Southwark smuggler and some disaffected officials among them. They seized Rochester and Canterbury, then marched on London, where they burned the Savoy Palace and breached the Tower itself. I knew very little about this history before I started. Now it feels like one of those crucial turning points where, if things had gone a little differently, the course of the country and probably the world would have changed dramatically.
Sixteen Days, Hour by Hour
The novel is structured as an hour-by-hour account of the rising, running from 30 May to 15 June 1381. In an interview with Foyles, Blakemore explained that the clock gave her guard-rails against the near-infinite ways of approaching such a sprawling subject. She tried to keep each "hour" to roughly one A4 page so she'd never linger too long with any single character. The result is a narrative that swings, within a few pages, from the Archbishop of Canterbury snoring in Lambeth Palace to a girl in a Canterbury gaol cell, and from the boy-king on his barge to an albino porpoise hunting fish in the River Blackwater. Every perspective is given equal weight. Blakemore even likes the idea of readers taking one chapter a day on the corresponding dates, which would be a wonderful way to experience it next summer.
It took me some time to get to grips with this ambitious and complicated narrative. There are a great many characters, and many plots, subplots and hidden schemes at play. Several of the characters also change their names as the story goes on. The ex-soldier Robert Crane rechristens himself Wat Tyler, is called "Waulter le Tieulier" by the authorities, and at one point is mistaken by a confused messenger for "Wat, the Tailor". His childhood friend Jack Shaw becomes "Jack Straw" (after his straw-coloured beard), and later "Jack Rakestraw". On my second attempt I created a character list to keep track of it all, and referring to it helped enormously whenever I reached a section where I wasn't sure who I was reading about. I'd recommend doing the same and you can download my guide here:https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ani0Sf1HSguNr0Y7j07I3cE5ivX_PGJj/
Who Was Wat Tyler?
Though the novel begins with a pair of friends, it feels like Robert Crane is the real heart of this story. So little is known about the historical Wat Tyler that Blakemore invents a backstory for him: a landless veteran of the wars in France with a burn scar across his cheek, who takes his new surname from the trade of his father, a roof-tiler. Early on, sheltering from a storm in an abandoned plague village, he encounters an unsettling, ageless crone. She calls herself an "instrument", claims to know his "regnal name" before he has even taken it, and has him drink a "milk of lightning" mixed with his own blood. She never reappears, but her words keep resurfacing in his mind and lend his whole journey an air of prophecy.
He's a flawed individual, yet I came to feel real affection for him as he suddenly finds himself at the centre of a revolt and gaining power beyond his wildest dreams. His storyline meaningfully grapples with the meaning of power and the expectations placed on him. It shows how he becomes prone to manipulation by more calculating allies like the smuggler Thomas atte Raven, and how all of this makes him a huge target. He's coarse and capable of horrible violence, but he's also sensitive, and there are moments where he shows real care for those who are vulnerable. The section where Robert recalls the dead and repeatedly alternates between calling them bodies, cadavers, carcasses or corpses takes on a movingly poetic quality. Shortly afterwards, sitting alone on a riverbank, he watches newly hatched crabs and realises he could crush a hundred of them with a single movement of his foot: "It's all relative, isn't it, power?" His exchanges with the preacher John Ball are down to earth yet contemplative, as they ponder mortality, the nature of governance and spirituality.
Robert and Jack
Robert's friendship with Jack, which opens the novel, takes many compelling twists and turns. Jack is the steady, prosperous family man, "the sensible one", and their bond is an uneasy mix of love and resentment, almost like brothers. There's also a steady, casual sexual attraction between these two longtime friends. I appreciated how the story doesn't seek to define their sexuality and presents their occasional physical connection as natural. I was also struck by how Jack comes to feel he has been absorbed by the name the crowd gave him, wondering whether we are only who the people around us make us. It's a question that hangs over Robert too as he steps into the role of Wat.
Face to Face with the King
It's dramatic and moving following Robert's journey as he edges closer to a meeting with the young King. One of the most powerful scenes comes at Rotherhithe. Wat wades waist-deep into the Thames, calling out to the royal barge, while the panicked lords literally pin Richard down in the stern and order the oarsmen to turn back. Each side's words are distorted as they carry over the water, so a plea for justice reaches the King as the howl of a wounded beast. It's a brilliant image of two worlds that cannot hear each other.
The royals and members of the court are interesting in themselves. Compellingly, there's an ongoing sexual relationship between King Richard II and his cousin Robert de Vere, the Earl of Oxford, and it's striking that Blakemore brings queer experience into her central characters' lives so prominently. In some ways King Richard is a comical figure, a naive boy with boyish impulses, but he also has a huge amount of pressure weighing on him. Like Robert Crane, he is prone to being manipulated and used by people with ulterior motives. Though he is spoiled and selfish in some respects, he's also canny in how he attempts to conduct affairs of state at such a young age. The novel captures the absurdity of a child not being allowed to be a child because he's born into the monarchy. His mother, Joan of Kent, is a terrific creation too: unsentimental, sharp-tongued and quietly frightened as she flees across the county that was her nominal inheritance. Blakemore notes in her interview that most readers will come to her Richard II via Shakespeare, and some of the novel's knowing, arch moments are a nod to the preconceptions we bring with us.
Why the Commons Rose
Above all, though, the novel is concerned with the working class and the destitute, who are ruthlessly taxed and used by those in power out of greed and assumptions about class. Though it's historically set, I think Blakemore is making a statement that there will always be a tipping point when the ruling classes abuse their power so badly that the underclasses will justifiably revolt. The entitlement of the upper classes runs up against the sensible notion that those who labour should enjoy the fruits of that labour, rather than handing their earnings to those in power and kowtowing to their demands. Yet there will also always be opportunists who see a period of upheaval as a chance to shore up power and wealth for themselves.
Blakemore makes the contemporary resonance explicit in her afterword, pointing out that nearly a third of land in England still belongs to less than one per cent of its population. In the Foyles interview she says that while writing she was thinking a great deal about the breakdown of trust in institutions, folk heroes and violence, and the ways power is distributed in a deeply unequal society.
A Poet's Eye
Some scenes have an almost cinematic quality as they zoom in and out. The narrator even invokes "the privileges of the deity or drone pilot" to lift us up and away from one scene to the next. Blakemore began as a poet, and her love of language is everywhere, from the earthy, swear-laden banter of the rebels to some gloriously obscure vocabulary. (I couldn't help noticing her particular fondness for the word "aperture".) She offers unique descriptions that capture the atmosphere of the period with humour, grittiness and wit, and she isn't shy about slipping in a modern phrase as a wink to the reader.
I especially appreciated her narrative trick of sometimes flashing forward to show the effect an individual or a dramatic clash has on the future. As Wat silently prays before meeting the King, the text cuts to a list of the modern roads, walks and country parks now named after him. A drover who pockets a pair of emerald earrings at the Savoy is followed sixteen generations down the line to descendants with private schooling and rowing machines. These moments emphasise the present-day resonance of events from the distant past. There are lovely cameos too: Geoffrey Chaucer, who really did live above the Aldgate in 1381, is glimpsed at his window watching the rebels' horses grazing beyond the city walls.
What's in a Doom?
The title itself is richer than I first realised. A Doom painting was a medieval mural of the Last Judgement, painted over the chancel arch of a church to frighten an illiterate congregation into obedience, with Christ enthroned above and the damned herded into hell below. In Middle English, "doom" meant judgement or justice as well as catastrophe, so the title points both to the reckoning facing the ruling class and to the justice the commons demand.
The image recurs throughout the novel, and each character sees their own version of it. Archbishop Sudbury dreams of a gory church mural from his childhood that was designed to keep labourers in their place. Joan imagines Kent spread out before her as a Doom, with the River Medway as its chancel arch. Richard pictures himself floating untouchable above the carnage, in the place where Christ would sit. Wat is more matter-of-fact: "Ain't the world a fucking Doom?" John Ball dreams of "Green Dooms! Gardens!", a renewal rather than a punishment. Like the great sprawling murals it's named after, the novel crams in figures from every rank of society and leaves you to decide where judgement truly falls.
What the Critics Said
The reviews have been glowing, though not without reservations. The Irish Times called it Blakemore's most ambitious and successful work yet, with a lovely description of Wat and his band going "medievally viral". The Historical Novel Society neatly summed it up as "history as poetic breaking news". In the TLS, Toby Clements praised Blakemore's poet's gift and compared the way she deals out her huge cast to shuffling a pack of cards. He also admitted to sometimes wishing she'd stop noticing things and describing them so beautifully. In the London Magazine, Joseph Williams admired how she makes Wat more central to events than the historical record ever does without turning him into "Forrest Gump in tights". He also notes how Ball's rallying cry, "we are many, and they are few", echoes Shelley and, much later, a Labour Party manifesto.
The most mixed response came from Sandra Newman in the Guardian. She called it "a work of reckless ambition" and recommended it very strongly, but she felt Wat's personality fluctuates too much from scene to scene, found some of the dialogue too much like action-movie banter, and thought the romance between Wat and Jack carried a whiff of modern fandom "shipping". I can see why she felt that way, but for me Wat's contradictions felt true to someone thrust from obscurity into leadership in the space of a fortnight.
Verdict
"Doom Painting" is a demanding read, and I'd recommend going slowly and keeping a list of characters to hand. As Toby Clements puts it, the trick is to take its richness in "small, grateful doses". But it rewards the effort enormously. It's a bold, vivid and politically urgent novel that made a distant chapter of English history feel alive, and it left me thinking about how much of 1381 is still with us. If you've read it, did you find the cast as tricky to keep track of as I did? And who would you cast as Wat Tyler in an adaptation? Blakemore's own suggestion is Will Poulter. I'd love to hear your thoughts.